Let’s not waste time.
The 2025 Chicago Bears look sexier than they have in years. New blood. New energy. New expectations. But let’s stop short of slapping a Lombardi on their media guides just yet. I’ve already broken down and scored all five core groups — quarterback, offensive line, offensive weapons, defensive line, and secondary. Now it’s time to pull those scores together and see where the Bears as a whole land in the Super Bowl pecking order.
No sugarcoating. No pipe dreams. Just a hard look at what this roster really is.
The Scouting Report: Five Core Grades
Here’s where each position group scored on a 100-point Super Bowl benchmark scale:
| Position Group | Score | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Offensive Line | 79.3 | Playoff Hopeful |
| Defensive Line | 65.0 | Playoff Hopeful |
| Offensive Weapons | 60.9 | Contender-Level |
| Secondary | 91.0 | Super Bowl Caliber |
| Quarterback (Caleb) | 58.9 | Playoff Hopeful |
Average Team Score: 71.02
Let that sink in: 71. That’s below the 75-point floor we’ve seen from most recent Super Bowl champions. Championship rosters clear 85. Great rosters sniff 80. The Bears? They’re stuck in the gray zone — exciting as hell, dangerous on the right Sunday, but still missing too many pieces to book a February flight.
Group-by-Group Breakdown: Where They Stand, Where They Fail
1. Quarterback: 58.9
Caleb Williams is not a bust. But he’s also not Brady, Mahomes, or even Burrow-level... yet. His rookie numbers — 87.8 passer rating, 208 yards/game, 1.18 TDs/game — are solid for a developing passer, but they’re JV compared to the Super Bowl blueprint. The talent's real. The highlight reel is real. The problem? His efficiency and production aren’t.
If Caleb makes a big leap in Year 2, the Bears could flirt with NFC Championship vibes. But realistically? He’s a year away from being that dude. You don’t win rings with hope at QB. You win with haymakers.
2. Offensive Line: 79.3
Thuney and Dalman form a nasty interior, and Jonah Jackson adds punch. But the tackles are still a problem. Braxton Jones needs a bounce-back. Darnell Wright has tools but hasn’t figured out speed rushers yet. Until that gets cleaned up, this group won’t be top-10. And we’ve got the receipts: 9 of the last 10 champs had top-15 offensive lines.
This line is playoff-good, not parade-good.
3. Offensive Weapons: 60.9
Now we’re cooking. Moore, Odunze, Swift, and Kmet form a legit arsenal. This unit exceeds the Super Bowl weapon benchmark of 59.9 — barely, but still. It's deep, it’s flexible, and under Ben Johnson’s mad-genius playcalling, it can rip teams up in bunches.
The scary part? They haven’t even maxed out yet. If Loveland flashes or Burden III breaks loose, this unit’s going to wreck box scores.
4. Defensive Line: 65.0
This is where the wheels get wobbly.
Montez Sweat is a dude. Dexter is on the rise. But the rest? Yawn. The Bears rank bottom-third in sacks and run defense. That’s not just bad — it’s fatal in January. No elite edge. No killer rotation. Too many snaps getting gassed out.
You want a title? You need to bring hell from the front four. This unit brings a stiff breeze.
5. Secondary: 91.0
Here’s your crown jewel.
Jaylon Johnson, Kyler Gordon, Kevin Byard, Jaquan Brisker — that’s a coverage unit that punches you in the mouth, takes your lunch money, and returns it with interest. They’re top-tier in EPA, top-tier in takeaways, and elite at bending but never breaking.
If the Bears go on a run, this unit will be why.
The Real Verdict: What Tier Are They In?
Let’s cut through the BS.
This Bears team is not a Super Bowl contender right now. They’re Playoff Hopefuls with real upside, but still a step below legit NFC bullies like Philly, San Fran, or even Detroit.
Here’s the breakdown:
Tier: Playoff Hopefuls (High Variance)
- Ceiling: NFC Championship if Caleb leaps and O-line holds
- Floor: 8-9, stuck in wildcard purgatory
What keeps them from true contender status?
- QB still developing
- D-line lacks juice
- Tackle play could implode
But don’t get it twisted — this is the best Bears roster we’ve seen in over a decade. If the young stars pop and the line holds, they’re in the conversation. They just ain’t leading it.
How Do They Make the Leap?
If Ryan Poles and Ben Johnson want to vault this squad into the real contender class, here’s the playbook:
- Caleb hits 85+ grade — he has to become a top-10 QB this year.
- Add a splash pass rusher — trade deadline, free agency, whatever it takes.
- Get Braxton Jones right — or find someone who can keep Caleb’s blindside clean.
- Interior stays healthy — Thuney, Dalman, Jackson are the engine.
- Ben Johnson goes full wizard — play-action, motion, RPO hell.
That’s your roadmap. That’s the Bears’ shot.
Final Verdict
The 2025 Bears are no longer rebuilding. They’re loaded at DB. They’ve got weapons. They’ve got the coach. And they’ve got the QB prospect everyone wanted.
Now comes the hard part: proving it.
This team should make the playoffs. But if they want to be anything more than a fun story with a cool offense, they need growth, guts, and a QB evolution that turns Caleb from talent into terror.
Right now? They’re playoff worthy.
Super Bowl-worthy? Not yet.
Comments
Join the discussion below. Keep it civil and focused on the content.
Loading comments...