White Sox Reportedly Make Mind Blowing Roster Decision

In a surprising development, the White Sox have reportedly optioned Tim Elko back to Triple-A. Cam Freeman of prospecting411 reported earlier tonight that Elko is back in Charlotte while also mentioning that Andrew Benintendi and Mike Tauchman, who were both on minor league rehab assignments, were not in the lineup for the Knights tonight. Putting two and two together, Benintendi and Tauchman will be activated from the injured list tomorrow with Elko likely being one of the roster casualties to make space for them on the 26-man roster.    

Elko's Initial MLB Stint

Elko generally performed as expected in his initial cup of coffee at the MLB level. He hit just .161 and struck out at a rate of over 31%, but also supplied his trademark power. He hit three home runs in ten games and his .452 slugging percentage ranks second-best among all White Sox hitters to record an at-bat this season. While he didn't light the world on fire in his short MLB stint, Elko showed promise and rewarded the organization for calling him up. He hit home runs, something the White Sox desperately need more of.

Andrew Vaughn's Job Security

With Elko reportedly heading back to the minor leagues, Andrew Vaughn's spot remains safe. The longtime White Sox first baseman is hitting just .189 with a .531 OPS over 48 games this season in what has easily been the worst season of his career to date. Not only has 2025 been his worst season individually, but he is also the worst player in all of MLB according to fWAR. Yet the White Sox organization has seemingly refused to give up on him despite having all the reasons in the world to do so.

Choosing Vaughn over Elko is a baffling decision on the surface. Not only did Elko outperform Vaughn in his short MLB stint, but this will almost certainly be Vaughn's last season in the White Sox organization. Barring a miraculous turnaround, they will not tender him a contract this coming offseason. A parting of ways is inevitable.

Bad Optics

Vaughn's draft status and salary are likely the primary reasons as to how he has survived on the roster this long. As a former third-overall pick who is one of the highest-paid players on the team, Vaughn has been rewarded with priority over a player more deserving of that roster spot. It is a bad look for the organization, to say the least. This news also comes on the heels of a telling admission from a former White Sox minor leaguer who publicly questioned Vaughn's work ethic and desire to compete.

Elko likely won't be in Triple-A for long. He has proven he is too good for that level, and all it takes is one injury for him to get another chance. Still, it is bad optics for the organization to prioritize one player over another for draft status and salary reasons.